The matter of Oreo, the ASPCA jerked us all around, telling lies and deceiving the public and handing out vague messages about Oreo, as late as today. I received messages from people who phoned their Bergh Hospital, saying that "Oreo has been killed" (info they were able to get only after speaking to ***EIGHT/8**** people), while other messages came in at the same time saying "NO she is still alive, until 3PM, according to info given to a NY Times reporter".
Shame on the ASPCA for this shame, for the execution of Oreo and for treating the animal-loving public like a bunch of fools!!!
The ASPCA, like HSUS and all the other money-grubbing-off-the-backs-of animals organizations, is doing what it always does...just making money to pay folks like Sayres the handsome salaries and benefits they enjoy, (think about this: @$500K/yr ...see 2007 report below), while animals like Oreo are confined to isolated cages and get destroyed when they become too much trouble or too hard to handle. They have no problem pleading poverty, (while their net worth is over $118 MILLION and they took in more than $85million in 2007), asking for our hard earned dollars and then ignoring our pleas when we want to step up to the plate and offer to take a problematic dog off their hands. Pets Alive, a well-known animal sanctuary in Middletown, NY, tried in vain to contact the ASPCA...repeated calls, emails were ignored. They are accustomed to dealing with dogs like Oreo and were prepared to offer her the care and nurturing she needed and deserved. They were unsuccessful and so were we. Please read the following statement issued by Pets Alive re Oreo's execution: http://www.petsalive.com/ and their blog: http://petsalive.com/blog/2009/11/13/aspca-new-york-using-your-donations-to-murder-animals/
PETS ALIVE CONDEMNS NEW YORK ASPCA FOR KILLING MIRACLE DOG
RECOMMENDS WITHHOLDING SUPPORT
Oreo, a one year old Pit Bull mix, was put to death this afternoon at the New York Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to animals. Oreo was the victim of serious abuse, having been thrown from the sixth floor of a Brooklyn roof top.
Oreo sustained two broken legs and a fractured rib in the horrific incident. She was nursed back to health. As part of her care she was “evaluated” by the ASPCA and deemed to be aggressive. Pets Alive, a Middletown, NY animal sanctuary, has spoken to volunteers and employees at the ASPCA and has questioned the methodology and results of those evaluations.
Pets Alive offered last night to accept responsibility for the rescue and rehabilitation of Oreo. Pets Alive has a thirty year history of rehabilitating animals deemed to be aggressive or unadoptable. “This is absolutely disgusting,” said Kerry Clair, Executive Co-Director of Pets Alive. “Animal organizations should not be adversaries, but when an organization that is chartered with protecting animals chooses to murder them when there are other options, they should lose the right to be called their protectors.”
We encourage supporters of the ASPCA to withhold financial support to a welfare organization that chooses murder over rehabilitation. They work for you, not the other way around,” added Matt DeAngelis, Executive Co-Director of Pets Alive.
Contact Information
American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals
424 East 92nd Street
New York, NY 10128
tel: (800) 628-0028
EIN: 13-1623829
IT KEEPS GETTING WORSE & WORSE
Another personal note from WAR: After telling many callers that Oreo was killed this morning before 10:00 AM, now we have been told by a New York Times Reporter that Oreo is still alive and scheduled to be killed this afternoon. There is still time to get a message to the ASPCA. Please keep the phone calls and the e-mails going. You can read the latest story here:
http://cityroom.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/11/13/deluge-of-pleas-to-spare-oreo-dog-thrown-off-roof/
Oreo's death will not be the end of this, but only the beginning.
On November 3, 2009 in a WAR action alert, we asked the question "what ever happened to Oreo", the young dog (1 year old) that was thrown from the rooftop of a 6 story Brooklyn building? Many of you wrote to the ASPCA and many of you forwarded the ASPCA's written replies to WAR. Mr. Sayres tell those who wrote that Oreo is doing well, still healing and that a decision has not been made about what to do next.
Now the whole ugly truth is starting to come out, as the ASPCA frantically tries to spin the story, in a way that will protect the ASPCA from scrutiny. See the New York Times story that was just published:
http://www.nytimes.com/2009/11/13/nyregion/13oreo.html
You can post a comment to the NY Times article and we encourage you to do so, as we are sure that the ASPCA will be reading those comments.
Please write to or phone Ed Sayres immediately. Ask them not to kill Oreo and that a well qualified sanctuary, Pets Alive, has already been located and confirmed.
Mr. Ed Sayres
President & CEO
American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (ASPCA)
424 E. 92nd St
New York, NY 10128-6804
e-mail: esayres@aspca.org
Telephone: 1-212-876-7700 Ext. 4603 - Direct line to Ed Sayres.
His secretary, Christine is at: 1-212-876-7700 ext. 4600 (voice mailbox may be full)
If the above voice mailboxes are full, check out the following contact page for the ASPCA and call any number listed and tell them that you want to leave a message about Oreo.
http://www.aspca.org/about-us/contact-us.html
Following is an open letter to Mr. Sayres from Win Animal Rights:
Open Letter to Ed Sayres:
Dear Mr. Sayres,
I represent the animal rights/animal liberation group Win Animal Rights based here in New York City. Win Animal Rights has both national and international affiliations. It was at our invitation that many activists contacted you at the ASPCA to ask about the status of the young pit bull that was thrown from a Brooklyn roof and "rescued" by the ASPCA. Many of our readers have forwarded your responses to us. Many initially believed the misleading information you sent them. Mr. Sayres, why are you lying to people?
We both know that the implication, in your e-mail responses, that you are holding Oreo until the end of the criminal action against Fabian Henderson, is untrue. Mr. Henderson relinquished ownership of Oreo to the ASPCA many months ago. If you had to hold her for legal reasons, why is it that you have given the order to kill her on Friday, November 13th?
We both know that Oreo is not still healing. If anything Oreo is now suffering from emotional abuse that she has suffered since being "rescued" by the ASPCA. She has sat in a cage with very limited human interaction. She wears an elizabethan collar 24 hours a day, seven days a week.....not because she needs it, but, because it makes her easier for your people to handle. This alone would make a dog crazy. How can you be so cruel?
Speaking of cruel, no doubt the ASPCA had the best of intentions when you "rescued" Oreo and put her through extensive surgery and a lengthy and painful convalescence, or did it have something to do with the media attention on the story and the thousands of dollars that have been received in donations for Oreo? Do Oreo's donors know that you are about to execute her? How do you think they would feel about their donation dollars being wasted and more donation dollars used to put her to death?
Why is it that you did not report, to those who wrote, about the ASPCA behaviorist advocating that Oreo was, in her opinion, aggressive and a liability and that she could not be rehomed? Why is it that you did not tell anyone that a second behaviorist has since been brought in (as ignorant as the first) to support the ASPCA's decision to kill Oreo? Did you think you could keep this information from the public?
How is it that you tell some that Oreo is getting plenty of daily human interaction when you tell others that she is vicious and cannot be handled by anyone? Seems like you are getting caught in the web of your own lies. Is Oreo vicious and unable to be handled, as your behaviorist claims, or is she getting plenty of love and human interaction?
It has been reported to Win Animal Rights, that the decision to kill Oreo was made some time ago and that only the ASPCA's fear of negative publicity has kept you from executing her so far. If negative publicity is a deterrent to killing, we would be happy to provide you with all of the negative publicity you can handle.
This letter and the facts of the case are being broadcast to every journalist, every blogger, every social networking venue and every animal friendly list in the world. If Oreo is executed, we will not forgive you and we will never forget such a shameless act of betrayal. You have my personal word on that.
Every individual life is precious. Please live up to your name, American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals and your mission statement. If the ASPCA cannot rehabilitate Oreo and undo the damage of over 5 months in solitude in an ASPCA cage, at least find a group that can help Oreo. We both know that there are rescue groups and sanctuaries that work with dogs with behavioral problems. I am sure they would be happy to release the ASPCA from all legal liability. We would be anxious to assist you in finding an appropriate rescue. You can reach me at: centcom@war-online.org
Until all are free,
Camille Hankins
Founder/Director
Win Animal Rights
http://war-online.org
Press Officer
North American Animal Liberation Press Office
http://animalliberationpressoffice.org
If you have any questions, comments or suggestions feel free to contact us at: centcom@war-online.org
Visit the WAR Calendar for future events: http://calendar.yahoo.com/winanimalrights
Visit the WAR MySpace page: http://www.myspace.com/winanimalrights
Visit WAR on Facebook: http://www.facebook.com/pages/Win-Animal-Rights/25169195791
For more info contact Win Animal Rights at: winanimalrights@optonline.net
Call: 646.267.9934 or visit the WAR website at: http://war-online.org